Timothée Chalamet's 'Marty Supreme' Transformation Was So Convincing, It Fooled Gwyneth Paltrow

Sometimes the best stories from a film set happen when the cameras aren't rolling. For "Marty Supreme," a hilarious on-set misunderstanding involving Timothée Chalamet's startling transformation has become Hollywood's favorite new anecdote, perfectly capturing the dedication behind his Oscar-nominated performance.

Timothée Chalamet’s physical transformation for his role in "Marty Supreme" was so convincing that it completely fooled his co-star, skincare and wellness mogul Gwyneth Paltrow.

During a recent Q&A for the film, Robert Downey Jr. gleefully recalled the on-set mix-up, telling Chalamet, "Paltrow told me when she met you, she was like, 'Oh my God, I didn't know he had bad skin.'" Downey Jr. added, "And I was like, 'It's [expletive] makeup, Gwyneth.' "

Paltrow herself confirmed the story on a podcast, admitting she even offered Chalamet unsolicited skincare advice for what she thought were real acne scars.

“I was like, ‘Oh, you know, you can do microneedling for that,’ ” she recalled, laughing. “And he's like, ‘This is makeup!’ I was like, ‘Oh, [expletive].'"

A Years-Long Commitment to the Role

The makeup was just one part of a years-long, obsessive preparation Chalamet undertook to become Marty Mauser, a 1950s shoe salesman determined to become the world’s best table tennis player

Chalamet’s journey into the role began back in 2018, when he started taking ping-pong lessons at a 24-hour facility in Manhattan.

His dedication was so intense that during the COVID-19 pandemic, he replaced the furniture in his Tribeca living room with a full table-tennis setup.

The training didn’t stop when other blockbuster projects called. Chalamet revealed he kept a “secret” table with him around the world while filming other movies.

“I had a table in London while I was making "Wonka." On "Dune 2," I had a table in Budapest, Jordan. I had a table in Abu Dhabi,” he said, adding that the training is all documented.

Chalamet felt a deep connection to the character’s ambition, stating, “In spirit, this is the most who I was that I’ve had to play a role. This is who I was before I had a career.”

From On-Set Gaffe to Oscar Buzz

That relentless commitment has paid off spectacularly. Chalamet’s performance has earned him his third Best Actor Oscar nomination, making him the youngest actor to achieve the milestone since Marlon Brando—an actor Chalamet has cited as an inspiration.

This awards season, he has already taken home a Golden Globe and a Critics Choice Award for the role.

The film, directed by Josh Safdie, follows the fictional Marty Mauser on his quest for table tennis glory. To become the character, Chalamet’s appearance was altered with makeup to create what Paltrow had described as "pockmarks" and "beady eyes with contacts and glasses."

Despite her initial blunder, Paltrow had high praise for her co-star, calling him "brilliant and committed and comfortable and confident."

Timothée Chalamet’s immersive work ethic ultimately created a performance so authentic it not only tricked his co-stars but is now earning him some of the highest honors in Hollywood, proving that his years of secret practice were well worth the effort.